Office Buzz: We Need Someone Yesterday

Grace had allowed the urgency to determine how thoroughly the company assessed the candidates. Management had pushed for speed but HR failed to communicate

Featured graphic for Office Buzz: We Need Someone Yesterday, illustrating the hidden costs of rushing the hiring process and recruiting under pressure.

“We need to start looking for a replacement.”

It was barely three weeks since the new Operations Manager had joined, but the Managing Director was already asking HR to find someone else.

The new hire had struggled to manage the team, missed two important deadlines and was having difficulty understanding the company’s operations.

“Didn’t we interview this person?” the Managing Director asked.

“We did,” Grace, the HR Manager, replied.

“And didn’t we check their experience?”

Grace nodded. She knew the candidate had not been her first choice.

The vacancy had come up unexpectedly when the previous Operations Manager resigned. His departure left the team without someone to oversee daily operations, and management was eager to fill the gap.

Grace had requested two weeks to advertise the role, screen applications and interview suitable candidates.

“We don’t have two weeks,” the Managing Director told her. “The team needs someone now. Find us a replacement by Friday.”

With pressure mounting, Grace shortened the recruitment process. She reviewed fewer applications, arranged interviews with the available candidates and sent the strongest CV to management.

The candidate had several years of experience and interviewed confidently. However, Grace had some reservations about their experience managing large teams. She wanted a second interview to explore this further.

Management wasn’t interested in another round.

“He has the experience. Let’s make the offer,” her director said.

Grace proceeded with the offer, and the candidate accepted.

Three weeks later, the team was struggling. Tasks were falling behind, staff were unclear about priorities, and the new manager needed more support than anyone had anticipated.

During the review meeting, the Managing Director asked Grace how the company had ended up with the wrong person.

She explained the recruitment timeline and the pressure to fill the vacancy quickly.

The Managing Director was quiet for a moment.

“We needed someone urgently. But we also needed someone who could do the job.”

It was a fair point. Grace had allowed the urgency to determine how thoroughly the company assessed the candidates. Management had pushed for speed, but HR had also failed to communicate the risks clearly enough.

They agreed to review the recruitment process, clarify the actual requirements for the role and involve the department head more closely in assessing candidates.

The vacancy had to be reopened. This time, management agreed to allow enough time to find someone who could meet the expectations of the position.

The experience left Grace with an important reminder: filling a vacancy quickly may solve an immediate problem, but hiring the wrong person can create a much bigger one.

Lessons for Employers

1. Urgency should not replace proper assessment. Even when a role needs to be filled quickly, candidates still need to be evaluated against the requirements of the job.

2. Be clear about what the role demands. A strong CV and a confident interview are not enough. Assess whether the candidate has the skills and experience to handle the actual responsibilities.

3. HR needs to communicate recruitment risks. When timelines are unrealistic, HR should explain the trade-offs and help management make informed decisions.

4. Hiring is a shared responsibility. HR can manage the process, but hiring managers must contribute to defining the role and assessing whether candidates are right for it.

WRITTEN BY
Elikplim Yaa Ayegbe
Jobberman Ghana
Notification Bell