When Derrick resigned, it felt like a mistake. Not on his part, on everyone else’s.
He was the one the MD referenced in meetings. The name dropped when the results were good. The “solid guy” everyone assumed would always be there. So when Derrick handed in his resignation, it landed like a shockwave.
The MD called him in immediately. HR followed. A counteroffer was prepared, with better pay, a new title, and promises of “more involvement.” But Derrick didn’t hesitate. No amount on the table was going to make him stay. Because by the time a high performer decides to leave, the issue is rarely money.
Derrick had been performing at a high level for a long time. He delivered consistently, covered gaps quietly, and took on responsibility without making a fuss. But somewhere along the way, the work stopped feeling meaningful. Growth conversations were postponed. Recognition came late or not at all. Decisions were made without him, even when they directly affected his work.
From the outside, everything looked fine. From the inside, he had already checked out.
The counteroffer came too late, not because it wasn’t generous, but because it didn’t address the real reasons he was leaving. What Derrick wanted wasn’t sudden appreciation when he decided to go. He wanted alignment, clarity, and a sense that his contribution mattered before he reached the exit.
This is the part many organisations miss.
High performers don’t usually leave loudly. They don’t threaten. They don’t complain endlessly. They adjust. They cope. They try again. And then one day, they resign, calmly, decisively, and without negotiation. By the time leadership reacts, the decision has already been made. Derrick didn’t leave because he was ungrateful. He left because he had outgrown the environment, and no counteroffer could change that. Counteroffers feel flattering, but they also raise a hard question: If the value was always there, why did it only show up at resignation?
So here’s the real question for you:
If your current company makes a counteroffer today, would you stay?
Table of Contents
Here is what to do when there is a counteroffer
When a counteroffer comes your way, it can feel flattering, even tempting. But it’s important to approach it strategically rather than emotionally.
1. Pause and Reflect
Don’t respond immediately. Take time to consider why you were ready to leave in the first place.
Ask yourself: Is this counteroffer addressing the root reasons I wanted to move?
2. Identify Your Motivations
Are you leaving because of money, growth, culture, recognition, or something else?
If the counteroffer addresses salary but not career development or the work environment, the underlying issues may remain.
3. Evaluate the Long-Term Impact
Most employees who accept counteroffers leave anyway. Accepting a counteroffer can sometimes change how your manager or colleagues perceive you, affecting trust and future opportunities.
4. Compare Opportunities Objectively
Make a pros and cons list of your current role versus the new opportunity. Include tangible factors (pay, benefits) and intangible ones (culture, growth, learning, work-life balance).
5. Communicate Professionally
If you decide to stay, make clear agreements: new responsibilities, career path, or development plans in writing. If you leave, give notice professionally, avoid burning bridges, and keep the conversation respectful.
6. Listen to Your Gut
Ultimately, your career is personal. Consider your long-term growth and happiness rather than the immediate gratification of a raise or bonus.
Gene’s Office Survival Tip:
A counteroffer is rarely about winning you back. It’s often about buying time for the company. Make sure you’re staying for the right reasons.
This is the Office Buzz!
Work, Culture and everything in between.
Remember to share this with that colleague who needs to read this.
