Hiring the right social media manager can make or break your brand’s digital success. With social media playing a crucial role in brand visibility, customer engagement, and lead generation, it’s essential to find someone who not only “gets” your brand voice but also knows how to deliver measurable results.
If you’re preparing to interview candidates for this role, here are 5 simple ways to spot the right social media manager during the interview process.
Table of Contents
1. Dig Beyond the Portfolio: Ask About Their “Why” and “How”
A beautiful portfolio shows what they’ve done, but you need to understand why and how they achieved those results. Don’t just admire the visuals; delve into the strategy.
During the interview, ask a question like, “Walk me through a campaign in your portfolio that you’re most proud of. What was the specific goal, what challenges did you face, and how did you measure its success?”
A great candidate will articulate clear objectives, discuss their thought process, explain the tools they used, and quantify the impact, for example, by stating that they increased the engagement rate from this to that. They’ll also openly talk about lessons learned.
2. Assess Their Strategic Thinking, Not Just Posting Skills
Social media is a marathon, not a sprint of viral posts. You need a strategist, not just a content creator. Test their ability to think long-term and align social efforts with business goals. During the interview, “If you were to develop a 6-month social media strategy for our company, where would you start? What are the first three things you’d focus on, and how would they tie into our business objectives?”
A strong answer will mention audience research, competitive analysis, platform selection, content pillars, clear KPIs (Key Performance Indicators), and how social media supports broader marketing or business goals (e.g., brand awareness, lead generation, customer service).
3. Gauge Their Adaptability and Problem-Solving Skills
The social media landscape changes constantly. A great Social Media Manager isn’t afraid of change; they embrace it and can pivot quickly.
Ask the candidate, “Tell me about a time a social media campaign you were running didn’t go as planned or received negative feedback. How did you react, what steps did you take, and what was the outcome?”
Look for resilience, a calm and analytical approach to crisis management, the ability to learn from mistakes, and a clear process for adjusting strategy based on real-time data or unexpected events.
4. Test Their Understanding of Analytics and ROI
A Social Media Manager must be fluent in data. They need to understand what metrics matter and how to translate them into actionable insights that demonstrate return on investment (ROI).
For example, ask “What are the key metrics you track to determine the success of a social media strategy, and how do you use those insights to inform future campaigns?”
The candidate should go beyond basic metrics (likes, followers) and discuss additional metrics, such as engagement rate, conversion rates, reach, website traffic from social media, cost-per-click (CPC), and audience demographics. They should explain how they use A/B testing or other methods to optimise performance.
5. Evaluate Their Community Management Skills
A Social Media Manager is the voice of your brand online. Their ability to embody your brand’s tone and engage with the community is paramount.
To figure this out, ask “How do you ensure consistency in brand voice across different social platforms? And how do you handle online community management, especially when dealing with difficult comments or customer service inquiries?”
The candidate should discuss guidelines for tone, content pillars, and examples of how they’ve handled both positive and negative interactions. Look for empathy, professionalism, and a proactive approach to community building.
Ultimately, hiring a great Social Media Manager requires looking beyond the surface. By asking questions that reveal a candidate’s strategic thinking, their ability to solve problems, and their deep understanding of analytics, you can move past the curated portfolio and uncover their true capabilities.
Struggling to find a qualified social media manager? You’re in luck. As we celebrate our 13th anniversary, you can now hire the perfect candidate at a special 13% discount. Find your next social media manager on Jobberman and take your brand to the next level.
